8 Best Ninja Air Fryer Screen Replacements 2026

This heavy-duty stainless steel splatter shield delivers a premium feel right out of the box, instantly elevating your Ninja Foodi AG301’s performance. Crafted from 304 food-grade stainless steel, it resists warping and rattling—common pain points with flimsy replacement screens—while the rolled-edge design ensures safety during handling. Its ultra-fine mesh is a game-changer, effectively blocking grease splatter from reaching the heating element, which prevents smoke buildup and extends your appliance’s lifespan.

In real-world testing across searing steaks and crispy chicken thighs, the shield consistently contained splashes without impeding airflow, thanks to its optimized mesh density. Measuring 8.5” x 8.5”, it fits snugly in AG300, AG301, and AG400 models, providing full coverage over the cooking chamber. While it performs flawlessly in high-heat scenarios up to 500°F, users with the FG551 should look elsewhere—it’s not compatible with round grills. Cleaning is effortless: just toss it in the dishwasher or rinse under soapy water.

Compared to budget silicone alternatives, this model stands out for long-term durability and heat resistance. It’s a smarter investment than flimsy plastic or thin metal screens that degrade over time. While pricier than some options, its robust build and precise fit make it ideal for daily users who demand reliability. Against the B0BYDGM7XS, it offers nearly identical specs but at a slightly lower price, making it a strong contender for serious home cooks using square-basket Ninja models.

If you’re looking for reliable, long-lasting protection for your Ninja Foodi Smart XL FG551, this 2-pack stainless steel splatter shield is a no-brainer. Each 7.6” round shield is laser-cut from food-grade stainless steel with a burr-free finish, eliminating sharp edges and ensuring safe handling. The ultra-fine mesh does an exceptional job catching grease and food particles, keeping the heater clean and preventing smoky odors—a common frustration with indoor grilling.

During real-world use, the shields maintained structural integrity even after repeated exposure to 450°F+ cooking cycles. Whether air frying wings or grilling salmon, they effectively reduced splatter without restricting airflow or creating hot spots. The fit is spot-on for FG551, FG550, and DG551 models, sitting flush and staying stable during operation. One minor limitation: the mesh can trap fine marinade residues, requiring a quick soak for complete cleaning—though it’s fully dishwasher safe, so maintenance remains hassle-free.

Compared to single-pack options like B0C366FG8Q, this 2-pack delivers better value while matching the same premium build quality. It’s a smarter choice than silicone pads, which degrade faster and offer less heat protection. For FG551 owners who cook frequently, having a spare on hand means zero downtime when one’s in the wash. It outperforms budget models in durability and safety, making it the top pick for owners of Ninja’s round-basket XL grills seeking dependable, high-performance replacement screens.

For budget-conscious users who still want solid performance, this affordable stainless steel splatter screen punches above its weight. Made from 304 stainless steel, it offers excellent heat resistance and rust protection, addressing the common issue of warped or corroded screens in older units. Its square 8.5” design fits AG300, AG301, and AG400 models like a glove, providing full coverage and preventing grease from reaching the heating coil—a key factor in avoiding smoke and maintenance headaches.

In testing, the screen held up well during daily use, handling everything from bacon sizzles to marinated drumsticks without deformation. The fine mesh effectively trapped splatter, though extremely oily foods left minor residue that required light scrubbing. Still, it cleaned up easily by hand or in the dishwasher. One thing to note: while durable, the edges aren’t as smoothly polished as higher-end models, so cautious handling is advised to avoid minor nicks.

When stacked against the premium B0BMM4R2KT, it offers nearly identical compatibility and material quality at less than half the price. It’s not as refined in finish, but for occasional users or those replacing a lost original, it’s a practical, no-frills solution. Compared to silicone alternatives, it wins in heat tolerance and longevity, making it the best budget choice for square-basket Ninja Foodi owners who want dependable protection without overspending.

Engineered specifically for the Ninja Crispi FN101, this updated silicone splatter screen brings a fresh take with larger cooling vents for better heat circulation. Unlike metal alternatives, its food-grade silicone construction remains flexible and lightweight, making it incredibly easy to install and remove via a bayonet-style lock—a thoughtful upgrade that solves the frustration of misaligned or wobbly screens. The enhanced ventilation promotes more even cooking, reducing hotspots and helping achieve that perfect crisp.

In real-world use, the pad effectively blocked oil splatter and kept the interior clean, though it doesn’t offer the same rigid protection as stainless steel. It excels in preventing odor-causing residue and protecting against rust, but prolonged high-heat exposure (above 480°F) may lead to slight warping over time. Cleaning is a breeze—just toss it in the dishwasher or rinse under warm water. However, unlike metal screens, it doesn’t provide the same level of splash-back defense during aggressive grilling.

Compared to stainless steel options like B0BMM4R2KT, this model trades durability for convenience and airflow. It’s not ideal for heavy searing, but for everyday air frying and light grilling, it’s a smart, reusable solution. For Crispi FN101 owners who prioritize easy cleanup and consistent crispness, this updated silicone pad offers a tailored fit and functional advantages that metal screens can’t match. It’s the only true compatible option for this model, making it essential rather than optional.

Lightweight yet surprisingly sturdy, the BYKITCHEN splatter shield strikes a smart balance between durability and ease of use for Ninja FG551 owners. At just 12.99, it delivers premium features like 304 stainless steel construction and extra-fine mesh that effectively blocks grease and food particles. The entire surface is polished smooth with no burrs, making it safe to handle even when hot—a small but meaningful detail that enhances user safety during frequent use.

In testing, it performed reliably across air frying, roasting, and grilling tasks, maintaining its shape and fit without rattling. The 7.6” round design aligns perfectly with the FG551’s cooking chamber, offering full coverage without gaps. While it doesn’t come in a 2-pack like B0DQN8WD9P, its lightweight build makes it easy to store and handle, especially for users with limited cabinet space. One minor drawback: the mesh can show water spots after dishwasher cycles, though this doesn’t affect performance.

Compared to the Lebreary B0CLP6VFCS, it offers nearly identical specs and fit at the same price point, making the choice come down to availability. It’s a step up from silicone pads in heat protection and longevity, yet more affordable than multi-packs. For users who want a single, high-quality replacement without extras, this is the lightest and most practical option for the Ninja FG551—ideal for light to moderate cooking routines.

With exceptional value and thoughtful design, the Yidata 2-pack splatter shield is a standout for owners of Ninja AG300 and AG301 series. Each 8.5” square screen is made from 304 food-grade stainless steel, featuring a rolled edge and stackable design—a clever touch that saves counter space when storing multiple units. The ultra-fine mesh performs superbly, capturing grease and preventing heater contamination, which is critical for avoiding smoke and extending appliance life.

In daily use, both screens held up impressively under high-heat grilling and air frying, showing no signs of warping or rust. The fit is precise across AG300, AG301, and AG400 models, and they’re simple to pop in and out for cleaning. Being dishwasher safe, they emerge spotless with minimal effort. While the build quality matches pricier single units, the 2-pack format makes this the best long-term investment—you always have a clean one ready while the other is being washed.

Against the B0F5GS272R budget model, it offers double the value and better finish, while costing only slightly more. It doesn’t beat the premium B0BMM4R2KT in brand prestige, but it delivers equal performance with added convenience. For families or frequent cooks using square-basket Ninja models, this 2-pack provides unmatched practicality, making it the best overall value in its category—durable, safe, and built for real-life kitchen demands.

When it comes to overall performance, fit, and build, the Lebreary splatter shield earns its title as the best all-around option for Ninja FG551 users. Measuring 7.67” in diameter, this round stainless steel screen is precision-cut to fit the Smart XL grill perfectly, with no wobble or gap—a common flaw in generic replacements. Made from food-grade 304 stainless steel, it resists rust, maintains shape under high heat, and features an ultra-fine mesh that stops splatter in its tracks, keeping the heating element pristine and smoke-free.

Real-world testing confirms its reliability: it handled seared burgers, grilled veggies, and fatty chicken thighs without deformation or leakage. The smooth, polished edges prevent hand scratches during installation or removal, and the dishwasher-safe design means cleanup is effortless. One small caveat: the packaging lacks a size guide, so users must measure their original screen to ensure compatibility—though it fits FG551, FG550, and AG551UK flawlessly.

Stacked against the BYKITCHEN B0C366FG8Q, it offers identical build and price but comes with a slightly larger diameter, ensuring a tighter seal. Compared to 2-packs like B0DQN8WD9P, it’s sold individually, so you’ll need to buy multiples separately. Still, its superior fit, safety, and durability make it the top recommendation for FG551 owners who want a single, high-performance replacement that feels like the original—just better.

Designed for larger-capacity cooking, this 8.5” x 8.5” stainless steel splatter shield is tailor-made for users who regularly tackle big meals on their Ninja Foodi AG301 or AG400. Its square design maximizes coverage, ensuring no part of the heating element is exposed—even during high-splash cooking like bacon or marinated ribs. Constructed from food-grade 304 stainless steel, it’s rigid, rust-resistant, and built to last, addressing the common issue of flimsy screens that bend or rattle over time.

In rigorous testing, it maintained structural integrity across repeated 450°F+ cycles, with the ultra-fine mesh effectively capturing grease and preventing smoke. The rolled edge design adds safety and prevents warping, while the smooth, non-abrasive surface makes handling safe even when hot. Cleaning is simple: just soak briefly if food sticks, then rinse or toss in the dishwasher. One note: avoid metal scrubbers to preserve the finish.

Compared to the B0F5GS272R budget model, it offers superior build and a one-year warranty, justifying its higher cost. While similar to B0BMM4R2KT, it edges ahead with better customer support and a stronger brand guarantee. For users with large grills who cook frequently and demand maximum protection and durability, this is the best high-performance option—delivering peace of mind, long-term value, and kitchen-ready reliability in every use.