7 Best Ninja Creami Extra Pints of 2026

If you’re serious about your Ninja Creami game, running out of pints shouldn’t be the bottleneck. The Omnikit 4-pack replacement pints deliver a thoughtfully upgraded experience with anti-slip textured walls and color-coded silicone lids—a small but game-changing touch for families or flavor enthusiasts who want to avoid mix-ups. These dual-wall, BPA-free containers are engineered for durability and a tight, leak-proof seal, solving the common frustration of freezer burn or flavor crossover that plagues flimsier alternatives.

In real-world use, these pints shine with consistent performance across freezing and blending cycles. The 16oz capacity fits perfectly within NC301, NC300, and NC299AMZ models, and the -22°F to 302°F temperature tolerance means they handle everything from deep freeze to hot rinse without warping. We tested them with thick sorbet bases and protein-heavy mixtures—the blades spun smoothly, and the containers stayed stable in the outer bowl. However, the lid seal, while strong, can be tricky to pop off after prolonged freezing, requiring a bit of wrist strength.

Compared to the pricier stainless steel options, the Omnikit set strikes a smart balance between affordability and functionality—it’s not indestructible like metal, but it’s far more resilient than standard plastic. It’s ideal for users who want extra pints without breaking the bank, especially those who value easy flavor organization and bonus recipes. Packed with a free 100+ recipe e-cookbook, this kit offers more value than most generic brands, making it a strong contender against similarly priced plastic sets—just don’t expect the premium feel of stainless.

When you need reliable, no-frills pints that just work, this 4-pack from Creami Pints delivers solid performance at a mid-tier price. Made from BPA-free polycarbonate, these 16oz cups offer crystal-clear visibility, letting you monitor your mix’s consistency before churning—perfect for perfectionists who tweak recipes down to the ounce. The upgraded sealed lid creates a strong barrier against freezer air, effectively locking in freshness and minimizing ice crystal formation, a common pain point with cheaper containers.

We ran these through multiple freeze-and-churn cycles with custard, sorbet, and even savory frozen dips. The material held up well, showing no clouding or warping after repeated dishwasher use. The -22°F to 302°F range ensures compatibility with aggressive freezing and quick cleanup, though we noticed the lids can warp slightly if placed on the bottom rack. On smooth surfaces, the pints rotate cleanly, but on thicker mixtures like cookie dough ice cream, the cup occasionally tilted slightly, suggesting a less aggressive anti-slip base than some rivals.

Against the Omnikit and Ninja-branded sets, this model trades color variety and premium textures for pure functional efficiency. It’s best for users who prioritize clarity, reusability, and tight seals over aesthetics or added accessories. While it lacks recipe guides or silicone bases, it matches the core performance of more expensive kits—making it a value-focused alternative for those who already have lids or prefer minimalist design.

Step into the next evolution of Creami containers with these 304 stainless steel pints—a bold upgrade that redefines durability and safety. Forget cracked plastic or lingering vanilla aftertaste; these shatterproof, odor-resistant steel cups eliminate microplastic concerns and withstand years of aggressive use, making them ideal for heavy-duty home chefs or health-conscious families. The built-in 4–20oz measurement scale is a brilliant touch, turning each pint into a multi-use tool for marinating, meal prep, or even freezing soups—far beyond typical ice cream duties.

In testing, the smooth steel walls allowed seamless blade rotation, with zero drag or resistance, even on ultra-thick protein ice creams. The silicone lids formed an airtight seal, and thanks to steel’s natural insulation, flavors stayed isolated with no cross-contamination after weeks in the freezer. We pushed them from deep freeze to hot water wash repeatedly—the steel didn’t dent, warp, or retain stains. However, the weight is noticeably higher than plastic, which may affect balance in older Creami units if not centered perfectly.

Stacked against plastic 4-packs, this set is in a premium league of its own—more expensive, yes, but built to last decades, not seasons. Compared to the 2-pack stainless model, it offers double the value for only slightly more per unit. For users seeking long-term sustainability, flavor purity, and multi-functionality, these are the undisputed champions. They’re not just Creami pints—they’re kitchen workhorses that justify every penny over flimsier alternatives.

There’s something undeniably satisfying about using genuine Ninja-branded pints—they click into place with precision engineering that screams authentic compatibility. These 16oz cups are the gold standard for seamless integration with NC299 and NC300 series machines, offering a perfect balance of clarity, grip, and stability during high-torque churning. The colorful BPA-free lids (lime, aqua, pink, gray) aren’t just eye candy—they make family sharing or flavor rotation effortless, solving the all-too-common ‘who made what?’ freezer dilemma.

We tested these alongside third-party models, and the difference was clear: less vibration, smoother rotation, and a tighter fit in the outer bowl. The frosted finish provides excellent grip, and the material resists scratching even after repeated use with thick nut butter bases. Cleanup is a breeze—dishwasher safe and stain-resistant, with no lingering odors. That said, like all plastic pints, they can develop fine scratches over time, which may harbor bacteria if not cleaned thoroughly.

For purists who trust only the original equipment, this set is the obvious choice—especially when you want guaranteed performance without compatibility guesswork. While pricier than generics, it undercuts the stainless steel alternatives while delivering Ninja’s exact design specs. Compared to the 2-pack genuine version, this 4-pack offers better value for multi-user homes, making it the ideal upgrade for loyalists who want reliability, brand trust, and vibrant organization in one polished package.

Don’t let the low price fool you—this budget-friendly 4-pack punches well above its weight with smart design choices that elevate the basic plastic pint. The transparent, frosted-body cups offer excellent visibility while reducing slip risk, and the included silicone base is a rare and valuable addition, ensuring the pint sits flush in the outer bowl for smoother churning and less vibration. For users tired of wobbly third-party pints, this stability boost is a game-changer.

In performance tests, the 16oz capacity handled standard ice cream bases flawlessly, and the -22°F to 302°F tolerance meant no cracking during deep freeze or dishwasher cycles. The silicone lids created a snug seal, though not quite as airtight as premium models—after a week, slight odor transfer was noticeable with bold flavors like mint chocolate. Still, for everyday use, they perform reliably and clean up easily. The stackable design is a bonus for compact storage, a feature often missing in cheaper sets.

Compared to other sub-$15 options, this kit delivers unmatched completeness—silicone base, color lids, and stable build. It’s not as refined as the genuine Ninja or stainless steel models, but for cost-conscious users or beginners, it’s a no-brainer upgrade from single-pint setups. While it lacks measurement lines or recipe guides, it covers the essentials better than most—making it the top pick for value without sacrificing core functionality.

For those who want stainless steel durability without committing to a full 4-pack, this 2-pack offers a perfect entry point into metal Creami containers. Crafted from 304 stainless steel, these pints bring serious longevity and flavor neutrality to the table—no more worrying about plastic degradation or ghost flavors haunting your next batch. The flexible silicone lids seal tightly, and the smooth interior walls resist residue, ensuring your protein ice cream won’t stick like it does in scratched plastic.

We tested them with high-fat bases and found zero adhesion or chipping, and cleanup was effortless—just a quick rinse or dishwasher run. The dual-purpose design really shines: we used them for overnight oats and protein shakes during the day, then froze them for ice cream at night. However, the 2-pack limits batch variety, making it less ideal for families or flavor experimenters. And while the steel resists dents, the lid’s flexibility decreases in deep freeze, requiring a warm-up before removal.

Compared to the 4-pack stainless model, this set offers identical quality at a higher per-unit cost, but it’s ideal for singles or couples testing the metal upgrade. Against plastic, it’s in a different durability class—light on scratches, heavy on performance. If you want long-term savings and multi-use versatility, this compact stainless set is a smart, future-proof investment—just know you’ll likely want more down the line.

Sometimes, you just need two extra pints—not four, not six. This compact 2-pack of genuine Ninja pints delivers brand-certified performance in a minimal, no-waste format. Perfect for couples or occasional users, these clear 16oz cups feature the same precise fit and BPA-free construction as the full 4-pack, ensuring flawless churning with zero wobble or misalignment. The lime and aqua color lids add a pop of fun while helping distinguish flavors—small but meaningful touches that elevate the experience.

In real use, they performed exactly like the original pints that come with the machine—smooth rotation, excellent freeze retention, and easy stacking for storage. We appreciated the lightweight design, which reduces strain on the motor versus heavier stainless options. Cleaning is effortless: dishwasher safe and stain-resistant, with no odor retention after multiple uses. That said, only two pints limit batch diversity, and the pack lacks the gray and pink lids from the 4-pack, reducing color options.

For users who already have two pints and need just a bit more capacity, this is the most logical upgrade—it avoids redundancy while maintaining 100% compatibility and brand integrity. Compared to the 4-pack, it’s less cost-effective per unit, but ideal for targeted expansion. If you’re not churning daily or feeding a crowd, this small pack is the smart, space-saving choice—authentic performance without overbuying.