9 Best Ninja Air Fryer Pan Replacements 2026

This dual-component upgrade for the Ninja SP101 delivers a rare combo of crisp performance and long-term durability, making it a standout in the crowded world of air fryer accessories. The stainless steel mesh basket maximizes airflow, ensuring fries and wings come out uniformly golden, while the non-stick baking tray handles delicate pastries and roasted veggies without sticking. Designed specifically for the SP101, SP100, and SP102, this set solves the frustration of using warped or ill-fitting replacements that compromise cooking results.

In real-world testing, the mesh basket shines when air frying dense foods like sweet potato wedges or chicken drumsticks—hot air circulates from all angles, reducing cold spots and eliminating the need to manually flip halfway. The thickened carbon steel tray withstands 450℉ with zero warping, maintaining structural integrity even after repeated high-heat roasting. However, the black coating on the baking pan may show minor scratching over time with metal utensil use, though it doesn’t affect performance. It’s dishwasher-safe, but hand washing preserves the non-stick surface longer.

Compared to single-piece replacements like the Ericair or GCQ models, this BRIKINTE set offers twice the functionality in one purchase—ideal for users who want both crispy textures and even baking without buying separate pans. It’s perfect for home cooks who regularly switch between roasting full meals and dehydrating snacks. While pricier than basic trays, its dual-basket versatility and robust build justify the investment over cheaper, single-use alternatives.

If you own an Ninja AF101, AF150, or AF161, this replacement tray is a no-nonsense solution to worn-out or damaged crisper plates—offering precision fit and reliable heat distribution without breaking the bank. The food-grade material is free of harmful chemicals, giving peace of mind for families focused on healthy air frying. Its strategic air hole pattern promotes even browning, whether you’re crisping up frozen nuggets or roasting fresh asparagus, solving the common issue of soggy bottoms in budget pans.

During testing, the tray delivered consistent results across multiple models, fitting snugly in both the 4 QT AF101 and 5.5 QT AF161 with no rattling or instability. The non-stick surface released food easily, even sticky marinades, and cleanup was a breeze—either by hand or in the dishwasher. However, the lack of a handle makes hot removal tricky, requiring tongs or oven mitts to avoid burns. While it handles standard temperatures well, prolonged use above 425℉ showed slight bowing after several weeks.

When stacked against the GWY or GXF models, this tray lacks a built-in handle or rubber bumpers, making it less convenient for frequent lifting. Still, it’s an excellent choice for users who prioritize exact model compatibility and simple maintenance over premium features. It’s best suited for occasional users or those needing a dependable backup. Though thinner than heavy-duty options, its affordable price and solid performance make it a smart, functional pick.

For budget-conscious cooks who refuse to compromise on safety, the Ericair 13×13 baking sheet is a quiet achiever—delivering chemical-free cooking and warp-resistant strength at a fraction of the cost of premium models. What sets it apart is its PFOA, PFAS, lead, and cadmium-free non-stick coating, making it one of the safest choices for health-focused households. The carbon steel base heats evenly and holds shape at 450℉, eliminating the dreaded middle sag seen in flimsier pans.

In daily use, this pan excels at baking cookies, roasting vegetables, and reheating pizza—foods release cleanly with minimal oil residue. Its wide, flat surface maximizes cooking space, perfect for family-sized portions in the SP101 or SP201 ovens. Unlike some competitors, it shows no peeling or flaking after repeated dishwasher cycles, thanks to its durable coating. However, it doesn’t include a mesh basket, so users wanting both air frying and baking must buy separately. It also lacks rubber bumpers, which can lead to slight shifting during basket removal.

Versus the BRIKINTE combo set, the Ericair is half the price but only offers the tray—a trade-off that makes sense for those who bake more than they fry. It’s ideal for students, small households, or gift-givers looking for a safe, no-frills replacement. While it doesn’t come with extra accessories, its clean material profile and affordability make it a standout value among chemical-free baking sheets.

The B0CFY4VFY5 baking sheet stakes its claim as the health-first choice for Ninja SP101 owners, combining chemical-free safety with serious cooking performance. It stands out with a PTFE, BPA, and PFOA-free non-stick surface, catering to users wary of synthetic coatings leaching into food. The 13×13-inch carbon steel pan resists warping at 450℉, maintaining flat contact with the heating element for consistent browning—perfect for sheet pan dinners or crispy-skinned salmon.

In real-world tests, the pan handled high-heat searing and delicate baking with equal ease, showing no signs of coating degradation after dozens of uses. Food slid off effortlessly, and cleanup required only a quick wipe or short dishwasher cycle. It fits snugly in the SP100, SP101, and SP201 models, though users with older units should verify dimensions due to minor manufacturing variances. While it performs admirably, it lacks a handle or bumpers, making extraction from a hot oven slightly awkward.

Compared to the GCQ or Air Fryer Grill Pan B0CCNCTV85, this model matches their size and heat resistance but prioritizes material safety over added features. It’s best for health-conscious families or those with young children. Though it doesn’t include a mesh basket, its focus on non-toxic cooking and long-term reliability makes it a smarter long-term investment than coated alternatives.

When durability meets smart design, the GCQ 13×13 grill pan emerges as the heavy-duty champion for Ninja SP101 owners who demand industrial-grade performance. Constructed from food-grade stainless steel with a Teflon non-stick coating, it withstands constant high-heat use without warping or coating failure. The optimized air circulation design ensures even crisping, making it ideal for everything from bacon to dehydrated apple chips—solving the problem of uneven cooking in flimsy OEM trays.

Testing revealed exceptional stability and heat retention, with no bending even after prolonged 450℉ roasting sessions. The Teflon coating resists scratching when used with silicone tools and wipes clean effortlessly. It fits the SP100, SP101, and SP201 like OEM, but users should verify exact dimensions due to slight model variations. While it’s dishwasher safe, aggressive scrubbing with metal pads can compromise the coating—stick to soft sponges.

Against the BRIKINTE combo set, the GCQ pan trades the mesh basket for superior structural integrity and longer lifespan. It’s perfect for serious home chefs or meal-preppers who roast daily. While more expensive than basic trays, its rugged build and consistent results make it a workhorse upgrade worth the extra cost over lighter alternatives.

For owners of Ninja’s round-basket models (AF101, AF150, AF161), the GXF 8.2-inch grill pan is a budget-savvy powerhouse that punches above its weight in convenience and safety. Its double-layer enameled non-stick coating resists peeling and ensures effortless food release, while the integrated handle makes hot removal safe and simple—a rare feature at this price point. Complete with rubber bumpers and a magic cleaning cloth, it’s designed for real-life usability, solving the common pain of slippery, handle-less trays.

In practice, the pan delivers crisp, evenly cooked results for chicken tenders, fries, and fish fillets, with excellent heat transfer and no hot spots. The 8.2-inch size matches OEM specs, fitting snugly without wobbling. It’s dishwasher safe and quick to clean, though hand washing extends coating life. The only drawback is slight flex under heavy loads, like a full rack of ribs, which can cause minor warping over time.

Compared to the GWY model, it’s nearly identical but often priced lower—making it the go-to budget pick with premium touches. Ideal for students, first-time air fryer users, or those needing a spare. Despite its low cost, its handle design and included accessories give it standout value over no-frills competitors.

For users of Ninja DualZone 6–8 quart models (DZ090, DZ100, DZ201), this 2-pack crisper plate set is a game-changer for high-volume cooking and easy rotation. Each 8.1×5.5-inch tray is crafted from food-grade stainless steel with a Teflon coating, delivering consistent browning and effortless cleanup—perfect for families or batch-preppers. The unique airflow design ensures even crisping across both baskets, eliminating the guesswork when cooking different foods simultaneously.

During testing, the trays handled double-duty meals—like chicken in one zone and veggies in the other—without flavor transfer or uneven results. The inclusion of 8 rubber bumpers and a cleaning cloth adds practical value, reducing noise and protecting the non-stick surface. However, they are not compatible with 10-quart models, so double-check your unit before buying. While durable, the thin edges can bend if overloaded with dense meats.

Versus single-tray options, this two-pack offers unmatched convenience for DualZone owners, allowing one to cook while the other soaks. It’s ideal for busy households who air fry daily. Though it lacks a handle, its dual-pack value and precise fit make it a smarter long-term buy than buying singles separately.

The GWY 8.2-inch grill pan is a thoughtfully engineered upgrade for Ninja AF101 and AF161 users who value safe, easy handling and long-term durability. Its enameled double-layer non-stick coating resists wear, while the integrated handle allows safe removal from hot baskets—a critical feature missing in most budget replacements. Made from food-grade material with rubber bumpers included, it’s built for real-world use, solving the frustration of slippery, handle-less trays.

In testing, it delivered crisp, golden results across fries, wings, and fish, with no sticking or hot spots. The 8.2-inch size fits AF100/AF101/AF150/AF161 perfectly, and the bumpers prevent scratching the basket interior. It’s dishwasher safe, though hand washing preserves the coating. The only downside is slight flex under heavy loads, like a full rack of ribs, which may require support.

Compared to the GXF model, it’s nearly identical in specs and price—making it a strong contender for best handle-equipped replacement. Ideal for frequent users who lift hot trays often. While not the cheapest, its ergonomic design and included accessories make it a more practical daily driver than basic trays.

Priced for value but built for performance, the B0CCNCTV85 13×13 grill pan is the smart all-rounder for Ninja SP101 owners who want premium features without premium cost. It delivers stainless steel durability, Teflon non-stick efficiency, and dishwasher-safe convenience in a single, well-executed tray. The optimized air circulation design ensures even cooking, making it ideal for roasting full meals or crisping frozen foods—solving the common issue of uneven browning in generic pans.

In real-world use, it handled high-heat searing and delicate baking with zero warping at 450℉. Food released easily, and cleanup was quick—either by hand or in the dishwasher. It fits SP100, SP101, SP1001C, and SP201 models precisely, though users should measure their old pan to confirm. Like others in this category, it lacks a handle, requiring care when removing from a hot oven.

Against the GCQ or Ericair models, it matches their size and heat rating while offering a better price-to-performance ratio. It’s perfect for budget-aware buyers who still want OEM-level quality. While it doesn’t include a mesh basket, its balanced mix of durability, fit, and value makes it the best overall pack deal for SP101 users.